New here? Register in under one minute   Already a member? Login244981 questions, 1084379 answers  

  DearCupid.ORG relationship advice
  Got a relationship, dating, love or sex question? Ask for help!Search
 New Questions Answers . Most Discussed Viewed . Unanswered . Followups . Forums . Top agony aunts . About Us .  Articles  . Sitemap

Can anyone give any insight to this.... Please read this long post

Tagged as: Big Questions<< Previous question   Next question >>
Question - (21 March 2007) 1 Answers - (Newest, 21 March 2007)
A male United States age 41-50, anonymous writes:

I wrote this quite lengthy letter to an advice column and I have not heard back about it yet. This particular Doc Love had written an article on the phrase "Let's just be friends" and explained that the love usually wasn't there in those cases and thus people shouldn't waste time on it. My letter is quite long and I don't know if anyone can be bothered reading it. But if anyone does I would love your insights into my troubles if you have any. The whole situation is kinda complicated and I'm struggling to understand/cope with it so any help would be appreciated.

Thank you.

----------------------

Hi Doc Love,

I read your article about LJBF ("Let's just be friends") and found it interesting because I have

been asking myself questions about the very same issue. The problem

here is that my whole life I have understood what that phrase means

and how to handle it, I have understood the womanese word "friend".

The reason I am so confused and bothered now is that this scenario

usually describes a situation that happens before there is a serious

relationship or in the initial stages of dating.

My situation, however, I feel is slightly different. I have been in a

relationship with this girl long distance for just over a year now.

Having said that though, out of the year we have managed to spend 6

whole months together over-all and at one point lived together for

three.

Our situation forced us to separate once again after that but it was

always my intention and still is to relocate so we can be together on

a permanent basis in the very near future.

However, what happened next is that she started feeling and talking

about how she thought she was keeping me back. How by being with her I

was forcing myself in to a situation that was less than ideal for me

and my future prosperity. While this is true in many respects it does

not mean that it's something that I am not willing to do or that I

would be eternally doomed if I did, it would be harder and I would

have to take different paths but I could still make my life a success.

However, as it is partially true and she seemed decided on pushing me

away for my own good I had to take time to think about it. (and yes, I

know it's hard to believe someone can be this selfless but for many

reasons I am inclined to believe her sincerity despite my occasional

moments of doubt.) The conclusion I came to was that my problem wasn't

as obvious as maybe it first seemed. That up until now I had been

doing certain things wrong in my life that I needed to improve rather

than going for the easy quick fix solution she had proposed for me. I

had also based some of my recent life decisions involving this

relationship on false or inaccurate information. I also realized and

decided that I had something very unique here and that I didn't want

to lose that. Now having the right information in hand I could base my

decision making on more solid footing and knew exactly where I stood.

I could also decide with my head more so than my heart like I have a

huge tendency to do. And fortunately, for once, my head and my heart

were in agreement. My final conclusion was that any path I might chose

however prosperous for me would only be half as meaningful if I didn't

have her by my side.

At this point though most our conversations had been about our current

difficulties and we were both growing tired of it, her probably more

than me because at points she seemed to get annoyed that it had to

come up in every conversation we had. The only reason it always came

was because I never really properly knew where I stood. So when I'd

reached my conclusions and tried communicating them to her she told me

she'd done some thinking of her own. That she'd decided that she

needed to spend some time with herself. That she'd lost track of

herself and now she didn't want any relationship, not with me or

anyone else. That she wanted time and space and to be left alone. That

she didn't want to do a long distance relationship anymore, that it

was too hard. And then also, the most frightening words in the world,

that she just wanted to be my friend... for now.

And here's the kicker that confuses, all the while she tells me that

she loves me. That she'd want nothing more than for us to be able to

find each other again down the road and have the chance at a real

relationship. Just a couple of weeks earlier I had had emails from her

expressing her deepest love for me. Before I left her for the last

time she gave me the most beautiful sincere card I could have

imagined. All the while this was going on she seemed really sad about

the whole situation and it seemed quite taxing for her. I've spoken to

her family and they consistently confirm to me that she indeed loves

me very much but that she just needs some space and that I should

focus on my own potential.

So that's where I'm at. I am trying to keep my distance for the

moment, we haven't spoken for what seems to me like an eternity. I am

trying to keep busy and work on my own things and improve myself as a

person in the ways I want to see growth. But I also want to and intend

to set my path in such a way that I will find myself in a position in

the near future were we can be together. It's just that I've been

pushed so far away at this stage that I fear that it might be in vain.

I am confused because she obviously loves me and pushes me away at the

same time. I am trying to figure out what best to do in my situation.

Should I completely ignore her and give up on it? Should I keep on

doing what I'm doing, giving her space, work on my own things, working

my way towards her, show up one day and say "I'm here now, I made it

happen. It was my own choice, do you want me?". Show her how strong I

can be and prove myself worthy? (surely I shouldn't have to do that

and she's told me on multiple occasions that I am more than worthy,

however true that may be) Or should I reach out to her and try and

convince her of how my decisions are sound and that we can have a

beautiful if she only cared to see it, wanted it and gave it a chance.

I've written her a long heartfelt letter detailing exactly how I feel

about her. I wrote it in the most positive, assertive, affirmative way

that I knew how. I detailed all her qualities and also illustrated my

own strength. I expressed my commitment to our relationship but also

my respect for her needing her space. I also told her that for now I

would remain content at being her friend but expressed that I had

every intention of being with her and I would never give up my love

for her.

It's a real letter, on paper, and I have yet to mail it. I just wanted

it to be out there, for her to know, concretely, rationally and

clear-headed exactly what my feelings for her were. Put it out there

and she what she'd do with it. I haven't mailed it for the fear of her

seeing it as an intrusion, me trying to push myself on her or being

desperate. For the fear that somehow it would illustrate her power

over me that I am not as strong as she would want me to be. All these

fears despite knowing that the letter is as sincere and beautiful as

any person could ever hope to receive and that I feel that it in know

way shows me as a weak person but rather shows me inner strength,

reserve and determination. Despite stating to her that she may have

the time and space she needs as long as she doesn't lead me on in

regards to her feelings about me.

So that's my situation and I don't really know what my real question

is, I don't even know if I have one. But your article on LJBF

certainly rang true with me for it's something that I've always known.

It's this interpretation of LJBF that I've always known that makes

those words hurt so bad when I hear them under these circumstances.

And that's also why I feel so confused hearing them in this context.

I've heard them before and responded with "But I love you" only to be

met with "I care about you a lot too". The message there is clear.

Never before have I heard LJBF combined with "I love you so much. I

love you more than you could ever realize and one day hopefully you'll

see how this was all for the best. And one day we'll hopefully be

together. Whatever is meant to be will be. I love you baby."

A very confused and insecure,

John

View related questions: I love you, insecure, long distance, needs some space

<-- Rate this Question

Reply to this Question


Share

Fancy yourself as an agony aunt? Add your answer to this question!

A female reader, birdynumnums Canada +, writes (21 March 2007):

birdynumnums agony auntI really don't have much insight into your situation, but I do remember having a friend in my youth that came to mind when I read your letter. We had crushes on each other from time-to-time - but never at the same time. We would probably say to this day that we love each other as friends and wish the best for each other. I suppose it was not our fate to become more than that. All that you can do at this point is respect her wishes and hope that your paths cross again. As it turned out, this person was not the love of my life and I did fall in love with someone else who I am still with thirty-five years later. I believe that things happen for a reason. If it was meant to be it will come to pass no matter what, and if not, there is something better for you still out there waiting. I have no idea if this helped at all. I hope in some way it did. Take Care and Best of Luck.

<-- Rate this answer

Add your answer to the question "Can anyone give any insight to this.... Please read this long post"

Already have an account? Login first
Don't have an account? Register in under one minute and get your own agony aunt column - recommended!

All Content Copyright (C) DearCupid.ORG 2004-2008 - we actively monitor for copyright theft

0.0156237000046531!