New here? Register in under one minute   Already a member? Login244961 questions, 1084299 answers  

  DearCupid.ORG relationship advice
  Got a relationship, dating, love or sex question? Ask for help!Search
 New Questions Answers . Most Discussed Viewed . Unanswered . Followups . Forums . Top agony aunts . About Us .  Articles  . Sitemap

I'm very attracted to a man who has kids and is separated. I'm torn about whether to move forward with him

Tagged as: Dating, Troubled relationships<< Previous question   Next question >>
Question - (24 March 2019) 9 Answers - (Newest, 26 March 2019)
A female United States age 30-35, anonymous writes:

Hi all - any advice or thoughts on the following would be much appreciated as I'm at a total loss, something very uncommon for me.

A series of events happened in my life that caused me to relocate to a brand new city without knowing anyone. I'm building a house and it turns out that I have a huge crush on my builder. Three weeks of texting and occasional phone calls, I find out he feels the same. However, something in my gut felt off about him. He is 6 years older than me and I'm very attracted to him on multiple levels - he goes the extra mile for me, he's smart, funny, handsome and just overall attractive.

One night on a call, I told him I'm worried there's something he's hiding and I'm not ok with him being married or having kids. Long pause - he has both. They are technically separated but it won't become official for another 4-6 months. I'm less worried about the wife and divorce and much more worried he has 2 children, ages 2 and 3.

I was floored when he admitted that. During one of our text conversations, I said something along the lines of expecting him to have a double life with a wife and kids. He responded "yeah, 12 kids and 3 wives, thought you'd be ok in being the fourth". So to find out he chose to make a joke of it really hurts. He said he wanted it to be an in person conversation because he felt it was too much to share over text.

Normally I would kick this guy to the curb and never think of him again. But there's something about him that makes me enjoy being with him and he tries so hard to make me happy.

I'm 27 and never once considered being with someone who is in the processs of getting divorced or having kids. On our first real date together, he admitted it might not be a fair question but wanted to know how I felt about moving forward with him. I told him I honestly didn't know. I feel sick when I see her name pop up on his phone and I never expected to like someone who had kids already.

My biggest concern is I'm old news. What is new and exciting about getting down on one knee or watching a woman walk down the aisle or being in the hospital room when she's giving birth when you've had all of that before? I've dated a ton of guys and have never had the same connection with anyone as I have with him. That's what makes the decision so tough.

I really need guidance and I have no one to turn to. I appreciate anyone reading this far.

View related questions: crush, divorce, text

<-- Rate this Question

Reply to this Question


Share

Fancy yourself as an agony aunt? Add your answer to this question!

A female reader, anonymous, writes (26 March 2019):

If you really want him do not be the rebound girl.Let someone else be that and get back to him later.Better chance of lasting that way rebound girls always get dumped.

<-- Rate this answer

A female reader, YouWish United States +, writes (24 March 2019):

YouWish agony auntYeah, I also say SLOW DOWN here!

This guy, with 2 kids and not divorced from his wife, is not in any position physically, emotionally, or financially to have a rich, full relationship with someone else. He has unfinished business, tons of baggage, and everything is way too fresh for him to bring someone else into his life in any capacity except a short fling or some convenient ego-boosting sex or companionship.

Financially, could you be with a guy who would basically be living off of YOUR earnings while his go to 16+ years of child support? And while you're working your brains out to keep up the expenses, the weekends he would have to spend with his kids most likely without you around.

Not to mention if he's not divorced, his wife might also make things difficult for him either by wanting him back OR wanting to punish him for "moving on" by withholding kids or dragging him (and you by proxy) through the court system.

Also, given he will eventually divorce, his credit rating will be shot and you won't be able to have your own home with the help of his credit and income.

His wife will also always be part of his life forever because of his kids.

Finally, do you know how many womens' lives are RUINED because they overrode something in their gut that feels "off"? How do you know what ended this guy's marriage?? Did you do a background check on him to see if there are domestic issues? Don't override the "something off" for any reason whatsoever.

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A female reader, mystiquek United States + , writes (24 March 2019):

mystiquek agony auntYou would be wise to step back and not get involved till you know more. He's already being rather shady and holding back information and that doesn't bode well. Why would he joke about something like that? Are you sure he's not a player? People will say all kinds of things when they want something, especially cheaters. Also, if he is being honest and is separated, they are NOT divorced. People go through a whole range of emotions when they are going through a divorce and their heads are VERY messed up. I know..been there, done that. Its just not smart to get involved with someone in that situation because they may still not be sure that they really want the relationship to end. Often couples do get back together, and where would you be?? Don't date him, don't have sex with him unless you are willing to take a big chance and get hurt. Wait until the divorce is final. Its the smartest thing you can do to protect yourself.

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A male reader, CMMP United States +, writes (24 March 2019):

What you really need to do is find out if he's still living with her. If seperated means "we live together but don't get along", that is just cheating.

But if he lives in his own place it's not uncommon for people to remain married for years after their relationship is over.

I would get more details. Another risk is that he still loves her and they're going through a rough patch.

Find out the truth(s) and don't feel like you need to move too fast if you decide to continue seeing him. Taking things slow would be wise here

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A female reader, Honeypie United States + , writes (24 March 2019):

Honeypie agony auntI think you need to pull WAY WAY back here.

NO dating etc. UNTIL his divorce is final and the "dust" have settled with the divorce and sharing of custody.

It will give him time to have worked through the divorce and you time to decide If you can DATE a guy who has "been there, done that" already. OR not.

One thing you DO have to realize is that, If you do in 6-8 months time STILL want to date him, HE will ALWAYS be a father first, and have to deal/interact with the ex-wife.

Do you know why they are divorcing?

To be frank, from what you write - I'd say he was hoping for a "little fling with you" nothing serious. The fact that he didn't mention the WIFE (she is STILL his wife) and the kids until you pressed and then he did so as a joke... it's a little dismissive.

He Is on the rebound and that might not bode well for you.

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A female reader, anonymous, writes (24 March 2019):

It is possible this man is still married and not separated. Have you ever asked yourself that? He's a builder and he's got looks and charm which he uses to his advantage. How do you know this isn't his "game" with other women? A ploy he's used before to get women into bed? He is still not ready emotionally and may even dump you if you have sex. If he's legit, last thing he wants is serious. I'd walk away. It's a shaky foundation.

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A female reader, anonymous, writes (24 March 2019):

If I were in your place I would see red flags flying all around. This man is married and has two children unde five years old. He has in progress, a divorce and custidy issues. You have no idea how much money this man must pay out in child support, allimony payments, and how much time he must devote to raising two very young children. He must continue to have contact with a woman who he has a long romantic and sexual history and who is the mother of his two kids. He is not very professional as he is getting involved with a client who he is working for, while the work relationship is ongoing. He has a very inappropriate sense of humor, joking about his broken marriage and home and two kids who must live in a single parent home. You feel like something is off. He was not forthcoming about marital status and dadhood. You will never fully trust him as you already see how unprofessional and inappropriate this man is, on and off the job! Trust me, there is more, but that is what I see, from what I have heard! NoWay

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A reader, anonymous, writes (24 March 2019):

You had to pull the information about his wife and kids out of him. Establishing your marital-status is at the top of the list; if you are pursuing someone romantically. That's not an "oh...by the way" type of discussion. Before any flirtations were exchanged, that should have been the first question.

The ideal and most honest situation is that he would have volunteered that information without being asked.

If a man dismisses the question or makes a joke of it; you should be very concerned. It's not funny, nor is it something to kid around about! He made sure you were getting attached first, then came clean. In my book, that move was manipulative. Your gut was telling you so.

There is little more to say than to tell you to proceed with caution. He's still married, and he's leaving his wife with two toddlers.

When a woman is falling for a guy, she listens to her heart more than what other people may tell her. So I advise you to guard your heart. Expect many bumps along the road; until his divorce, child-custody, and visitation issues are completely resolved. Feelings fluctuate and emotions run high. His wife will still have to deal with becoming a single-mother, the finalization of her marriage; and then accepting a new woman in his life. That takes time.

Baby-mama drama is for certain, unless you know it is an amicable divorce. You also know, having two very small children will take a lot of his time and attention away from you. His soon to be ex-wife will abruptly interrupt your time together; when the kids are sick, or want to see him.

They are co-parenting; so she will always be in the picture.

The children are very small; so he has to maintain a very close bond with them. They don't understand anything yet.

Try not to be too starry-eyed. Stay level-headed. There will be some emotional and legal hurdles to get-over before he's home-free.

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A female reader, Youcannotbeserious United Kingdom + , writes (24 March 2019):

Youcannotbeserious agony auntAll I can say is that life seldom pans out EXACTLY as we envisage. If you put it out there that you will NEVER fall for someone who is/has XYZ, you can almost guarantee the universe will challenge that and show you that life is not that black and white.

IF you are going to move forward with this relationship, you need to do it VERY SLOWLY and VERY CAREFULLY. Also you need to get over the "I will not be the first" attitude. This guy's wife had the "firsts" with him but it still didn't work out in the long run. Often second time around is better because you are older and wiser and appreciate things more. It may he his second time at stuff but it will still be his FIRST time with YOU. If you cannot get past that, then I would say you need to walk away and give up on this man as your insecurity will eventually kill the relationship.

His ex will ALWAYS be part of his life because they will always be parents to the same two children. Whenever anything major happens, he will need to be there. It is to be hoped he will be a hands-on father, which will involve spending as much time as he can with the kids. If you are insecure about this, then, again, you need to let this man go. He comes as a package. He would not be much of a man if he did not put his children at the top of his priority list. (I would not be too concerned about him wanting to tell you about his kids in person rather than by text; that just sounds sensible, given the important of the information which was to be shared.)

If you are wanting children of your own, you also need to find out if he wants more children.

Here's a suggestion. How about you hold off dating until his divorce has been finalised? This will give you time to think things through, get to know him better as a person (contact ok but no dating). Another 6 months down the line, things may look very different again.

You have the rest of your lives. Don't rush things. Good luck.

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

Add your answer to the question "I'm very attracted to a man who has kids and is separated. I'm torn about whether to move forward with him"

Already have an account? Login first
Don't have an account? Register in under one minute and get your own agony aunt column - recommended!

All Content Copyright (C) DearCupid.ORG 2004-2008 - we actively monitor for copyright theft

0.0312707999983104!